Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness

[animalcrossingrox]

No, but it's better than we only come out at night by far

[Sam Davis]

I think its alright, take out a few ballaRAB and 'We Only Come out At Night' (my reaction to that is only ever 'what the f**k?) and its alright. Nothing compared to Siamese Dream and Gish, but still.

[hippyboy92]

I can't believe the number of you who don't like this album! I'm actually quite shocked.

[Pythagoras]

There`s a shock
What is it about you loving EVERY SINGLE ALBUM I hate?

[The Mad Hatter]

I totally disagree.

[Umm Zekiya]

there is a lot of dross on that album

you filter out all the crap and you have a really good LP with 14 tracks on it

[mia babyy]

lol, it isn't that negative!
But you really got hatemail for this?

[BekindtoAnimals22]

Generally, I agree with you. I would say I like this album, but the truth is when I listen to it I usually don't get past An Ode to No One. But I'm not quite as critical as you are, so I'd say I like it based on Zero, Jellybelly, Bullet with Butterfly Wings, and the fact that the other songs aren't actually BAD - just not great.

And of course, Corgan is a controlfreak douchebag and shouldn't be trusted with an album. I'll agree that Siamese Dreams is better, but I'd probably still give it more than a 1.5.

[BeautifulEyes<3]

I think it's good, but it's not the best by any margin. ha I'm actually listening to them as I write this...

[Darrickw]

Its only meant to be a fun ditty, in these terms its great.