Music Banter Hall Of Fame: Nominations Thread

[xMuscleMilkx]

Hmm no they are quite hit and miss, Mothers Milk, BSSM, TUMPP and Freakey Styley are all good but other than that no and they aren't really HoF material.

PS Flea most overrated Bassist ever? he's good but not the best how he's in so many top tens I don't know.

[LolaMesser]

When then lets say **** you to Black Sabbath for all the **** they did with Dio then.

And I never said anything about their early albums, Yes was an average but decent enough debut, and Time and a Word is actually pretty damn good.

And not all their later albums are bad either. Their last two albums were good, they mark a return to their prog roots and the traditional lineup. Hell Magnification was pretty much the best thing they've done since Going for the One. They only have 5 truly mediocre/bad albums IMO, hardly any more than Pink Floyd, and hell, Genesis, Jethro Tull, ELP and Moody Blues have all put out more sh*t than Yes ever did, the amount of crap Yes have put out is actually relatively small for a 70s prog band.



They were only pop briefly, it started with Drama, which was a very good album, then even furthur with 90125, which was still good. They only have a few albums I'd call horrible, Big Generator, Union and Open Your Eyes, that was their bad pop/arena rock phase. Tormato and Talk are pretty mediocre but had a few redeeming qualities.



They still have more good albums than bad ones.

[Sandy in Grease!]

Who was that directed at?

[Greek Gamer]

Goddamn the recent nominations have been boring. I'll abstain. Yawn...

[Tanner]

Looks like you've been hanging around MissMurder a bit too much...

[Bunniculette]

I'm still incredibly torn....ok I'm voting yes. The staying power of their radio hits is enough for me to go off of.

But I'm pretty upset Yes didn't make it into the HOF.

[Ty Kapitzky]

Chuck Berry? Garbage? I'll refrain from mentioning Jesus & The Mary Chain....

OOPS!



All I ask is that we make up our damn minRAB.

It's either "vote for who you like" or "vote for those that deserve it based on impact and influence". Not "pick whichever option you feel like choosing at any given time".

[EmokittyOMG]

This. It was 100% percent a parody of grunge and them fooling around with the American 'underground'. It's sad that it is basically the only song my frienRAB know blur for.

[Mannat Bhatia]

Pretentious ****heaRAB who are getting known off of other banRAB' formulas. Anything after Pablo Honey pales in comparison. They're past their prime and to even call them the most talented band around is an insult to banRAB with artistic integrity.

Its a yes from me.

[iloveyouu]

Well obviously sir, "Hey hey you you I don't like your girlfriend." "I think you need a new one".......