!!!Star Wars!!!

[Razgriz]

I do wish Mr Lucas had given us a great xmas prezzie with a rerelease of EP3 i would have love to see Vader force chocking that big ape and that boy wizard at the box office,i am heartily sick of all of these critics,magazines,teletext ceefax slagging off Star Wars all of the time,its really sticking in my craw!!!

[McIntyre2K7]

I heard that Harrison Ford hated Star Wars to.
Thats not true is it?
I was always under the impression he liked it quite abit...

[misty c]

Thats what i thought to, its like when Episode 3 came out they were saying 'This could be one of the best movvies of all time and its so brilliant!!!' And now there all like 'Harry Potter has beaten StarWars by a long shot and i can see why' Quite frankly it really pi*s'sme off.

[volleyballchick]

I think Harrison Ford probably doesn't hate Star Wars, he continued to work with Lucas on Indiana Jones etc. If he had hated Star Wars I can't see why he would of continued to work with its director on other projects.

I really enjoyed Revenge of the Sith, heres my ratings...

TPM - 7 - I believe at the time it seemed awful, but looking back now it wasn't as bad as I thought.

AOTC - 6 - I thought it was a lot better then TPM, but since ROTS I've liked TPM more and AOTC less.

ROTS - 8 - Very good and very glad to see many people seemed to enjoy it.

ANH - 9 - Great start and will always be a cinema masterpeice.

TESB - 10 - Brilliant, it has everything a Star Wars movie should.

ROTJ - 8 - Very good film and a great end to the saga.

[I love Animals]

Interesting to see everyone giving the critics' choice ESB 10/10.

Personally, I feel that this is the weaker of the original three - it's overly long, there's very little plot advancement and we're left with unresolved issues at the end. Oh, and thanks to George, there's no suspense or surprise at the "I'm your father" bit, either

My marks:

TPM: 6
AOTC: 7
ROTS: 8
ANH: 9
ESB: 7.5
ROTJ: 9

And yes, I love the ewoks, so sue me

[dwdrummer06]

He wasnt the only one.

[PB46]

Id rate:

A New Hope - 10
Empire Strikes Back - 10
Return Of The Jedi - 8

Phantom Menace - 6
Attack Of The Clones - 7
Revenge Of The Sith - 8

[Taylor<33]

No, although he thought Solo should be killed off early on in Jedi. Not because he wanted out, but he thought that the stakes needed to be raised for the final act, and that Solo should make the "ultimate sacrifice" to complete his character arc.

Oh, and and if we're playing that game:

A New Hope - 9
Empire Strikes Back - 10
Return Of The Jedi - 10

Phantom Menace - 5
Attack Of The Clones - 2
Revenge Of The Sith - 7

[t909y]

I see ,cool thanks.

ANH- 9
ESB-10
ROTJ-9

TPM-8
ATOC-5
ROTS-9

[Tom Gainer]

Who else did?