I'd like to know whether your car has steel rims with hubcaps, or alloy wheels. The former are susceptible to dents and warping. Alloys typically get chipped from impacts with curbs, although this kind of damage can sometimes be repaired. I think your friend gave you good advice about getting a second opinion. Try an independent repair shop, preferably one that has a good reputation.
Now, I am assuming that your car is the Legacy L sedan, since you did not specify which of the 5 trim levels available for that year you have. If that's what you have, the stock wheels are 6" with a 50mm offset and a 5-100 bolt pattern. You take a 205/60-R15 tire. Those are the numbers you'll need when shopping for rims for your car. If you decide to go the junkyard route, that's what you'd need to tell them about the wheels.
A quick look at your car over at Tire Rack does not indicate that there are any inexpensive 15" steel rims with hubcaps available there for your car, but they have aftermarket alloy wheels - which can look pretty nice - starting at $69 each. That may or may not be cheaper than what your dealership would charge for factory wheels, assuming they're available. You could also move up to a 16 or 17, although a 17 on your car might look a little "rice-y."
http://www.tirerack.com/wheels/results.jsp?filterSize=15&filterFinish=All&filterB rand=All&filterSpecial=false&filterNew=All&autoMak e=Subaru&autoModel=Legacy+L+Sedan&autoYear=2000&au toModClar=&sort=Brand
For the Legacy GT Limited, which has 16" wheels stock, there is one steel rim available there, at $49, but it's sold out for the season. People buy them for winter tires. Their 16" alloy rims start at $86 each (for what they have in stock). The bolt pattern and offset are the same as the 15s.
http://www.tirerack.com/wheels/results.jsp?filterSize=16&filterFinish=All&filterB rand=All&filterSpecial=false&filterNew=All&autoMak e=Subaru&autoModel=Legacy+GT+Limited&autoYear=2000 &autoModClar=&sort=Brand
I have had very good experiences with this merchant. If you buy tires from them at the same time as the wheels, they'll mount and spin balance them for you before they ship - which can save you a lot of money.
Bookmarks