I have an option for an upgrade on either of the above phones. I am used to having a nokia and my current phone is a nokia 6230i so its pretty basic. Im leaning towards the nokia as it has a good camera and is a candy bar design. As im out of touch with smart phones I thought id ask here and see what people think.

Thanks for your advice
I forgot to add I have been offered this by my serviceprovider as a way of going from payasyougo to pay monthly. I dont intend to use the phone for much other than calls, texts, a tiny bit of surfing but mostly im interested in the features within the phone i.e. good quality camera and other quirky features. One that can support common apps would be great also. I know nothing about smart phones so my decision could hinge on what you say. Iphone is not an option, only the 4 handsets ive listed. Thanks