Music Banter Hall Of Fame: Nominations Thread

[Natalie]

oh my science my face hurts from palming it so hard

[rehman]

I'm still debating the issue. On one hand they produced brilliant songs like Rarable Tarable and Run Through the Jungle and are well respected by even the punk ideologists who disavowed classic rock. On the other they were all over the place on even their best albums and churned out shit songs with the rest of them.

In a toss-up between the Dead and CCR, I've got to go with the Dead every time, but I'm not sure how that's relevant to whether they were HOF material.

[Judy b]

You think everyone should get a vote just like the first round?

[lalala]

I really havent heard enough to say yes or no..Im not gonna vote. I didnt like what I did listen to, just not my thing. That said I know their impact has been big..so its a null vote for me.

[[[---Dark---]]]

seeing as this is the first time that i and many others have even heard of them, i don't feel that they should be in the HoF, a place which is supposed to represent the shared tastes of most of the people here.

[ThangQanime]

You will make a great politician answering a question with a question.

It is not a matter of being a fan or a non fan. I am just curious as to why he should be included in a Hall Of Fame.

[Monica B]

yeah...Morrissey for Prime-Minister:thurab:

[Tavo E]

I just think it's curious, is all. Of course that's not why I voted no.

[viky_khanna]

I'm sorry, I figured 'Hall of Fame' as the hall of famous musicians. Not a list of favorites. Sort of like the baseball hall of fame.

[khamis0o]

While I haven't been convinced to vote yes, I can assure you I'll be giving Iron Maiden some more listens in the near future.