Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness

[Nich!]

I like smashing pumpkins. Just popping in to say HI!

[Kitty Kattt]

Yeah, I'll say Siamese Dream was a lot better than this one. Mayonnaise was my fav. tune off of that one, they were all pretty good. I think 33 of Collie was decent. Jimmy Chamberlain 1 of my fav. drummers. Listen to the drumming on Siamese Dream. It rocks the Casbah!

[iga k]

Nah, Siamese Dream is definitely my favorite album. Gish and Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness are close seconRAB. "We Only Come Out at Night" is definitely not a highlight off of Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. What is "Wild Honey Pie"? I've never heard of that song.

[Troy W]

Too clean for you, Subpop?

I quite like Melon Collie. I find Gish a bit too messy.

Machina and the Machines of God has one of the worst second halves to any album I've ever heard.

[Matt W]

Hmmm, I bought this one within a week of release. It is still sitting on a shelf collecting dust. It might have gotten one full listen over the years.

[engtuner01077]

Nice detailed review.

[Church]

Damn good call.

[gear_head26]

I bought this album yesterday. Wow, it really does blow. I'm glad I bought it used.

[Lavern logel]

Agreed, Siamese dream is just a perfectly done album.

[lionaness813]

I prefer Gish over this album...Even Siamese Dreams.