All Time Favourite Pink Floyd Track?

[polk-dotz]

Learning To Fly

[RODDERS790]

See Emily play for sure! So whimsical and childlike!

[sza]

^Yuck. Sorry but I don't get the hype/credit or whatever that people like that song. Weird and boring noises and iffy vocals for me.

EDIT: To the 'Welcome To the Machine' vote by Alfred.

[Bon-bon]

The Wall is a fine album, overrated sure, but a fine album.

I can't understand the backlash from so many hardcore fans of Floyd against them.

[Twilight Lover Forever!]

Echoes is sublime.

[latnot]

"Wish You Were Here," though it was tough choosing.

[volleyball babe<3]

I wanted to say something original like Free Four but I have to say Wish You Were Here. That song brings out so many emotions and can mean so many things yet it has a simple message. I put it on so many mix tapes as a kid...lol.

[Ms Thang]

Same criteria as The Beatles thread.

I am hoping this has'nt been done before. I will make an official thread when all the nominations are in ONE MONTH from today. Choose your track and explain why you chose it. I will then compile a rab top ten poll and use the best appraisals for each song in the top ten. GO.

Voted:

Dogs - 5
See Emily Play - 4
Echoes - 1
Interstellar Overdrive - 1
Welcome To The Machine - 1
Comfortably Nurab - 2
Wish You Were Here - 5
Us & Them - 2
Time - 2
Pigs (Three Different Ones) - 1
Astronomy Domine - 1
Pow R. Toc H - 1
The Great Gig In The Sky - 1
Breathe - 1
Learning To Fly - 1
Bike - 1
Any Colour you like - 4
The Fletcher Memorial Home - 1

[gv_girl]

My favorite is Time. The vocals and guitar solo fit the song absolutely perfectly, and I like the... piano? organ? accompaniment. It's subtle but also fits.

[ramonesfan05]

I'm pretty much in the same boat as you, except I feel I could never actually pick a favorite, only favorites.