NOEL GALLAGHER: a genius or a dumb?

[twilight fan11]

he was a good songwriter

[Runj N]

:crazy: yeh with all the **** going on between Liam and Noel, listen to Wibbling Rivalry

[robzuc97]

Like, honestly! You'd think it were MY fault that Jay-Z is just not a very good rapper. Strummer, dude, it's not my fault. Get over it already.

[Wtekal Aooriq]

I think he's a genius and I love his songs....

U?

[hdoraisamy]

Well he's not a genius, one awesome album a genius does not make (as Yoda would say)
He's not durab though, he can be quite witty at times and he must be doing something right to have that fanbase.

[TopSecret]

Neither, really great songwriter & a even better guitar player, but he's neither. I look forward to his solo album.

[Kirino]

"The secret to creativity is knowing how to hide your sources." - Albert Einstein.

[JimbossJ]

I'm sure they had some right laughs, but they normally sound as bored as **** on record.

[AlmaaPattinson]

What that tells me is that neither you nor sweet_nothing appreciate or even respect what was good about I Am The Walrus in the first place! Lennon's quirky and idiosyncratic, disturbing, ominous, sinister, brooding depiction of a schizophrenic nightmare... ripped out, chewed up, and spat out as an Oasis cookie-cutter staple. A bastardization if ever there was one...

[Emma-lee]

^ I don't entirely agree with this...



...but that ^ is a great description of I am the Walrus.