I just bought an LG Bluray player (BD350C), and hadnt had a chance to rent a Bluray disc yet so I was watching a regular DVD on it (several different discs) and had no issues.

We finally rented a bluray disc today (looks 100% perfectly fine, not a single scratch or imperfection on it) and it attempts to load for about 30 seconds while in the top left it displays "Bluray Disc",

After 30 seconds or so each and every time I tried, it says "ERROR" on the player and on the screen it says "check disc". but again, the disc is practically flawless. (Some of the DVDs I had in there were no where near as good condition and played fine).

This was an "open box" player from futureshop and it was the last one (they are no longer going to carry this particular model anymore). Does this sound like a problem with my bluray player reading bluray discs? Or is it probably somehow the discs error?